Skip to Content

PHIL 3013/5193/6193
Weekly Assignments

    • The default is to outline the passage I assign.
    • If you choose a different passage:
      • make sure it contains an argument.
      • you have to tell me what it is. (I'm not a mind reader.)
      • please make it terse---a paragraph or two, not a chapter, or anything like a chapter. (I have to read the passage side by side with your outline, to check that the latter correctly represents the argument in the former.) My experience is that attempts to outline longer stretches of text don't generally work out well.
  1. Aug. 22 (for those of you who have already taken a class from me, who know what these outline assignments -- not the same as microcommentary assignments! -- are supposed to look like, and who want to get an early start): T I.i.6 (first para. of the section, starting "I wou'd fain ask those philosophers..."; p. 15f in the Selby-Bigge, p. 16 in Norton and Norton). (If the terms "substance" and "accident" are new to you, check out http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/substance/, but there's no need to read all of it: just look at the first couple paragraphs of sec. 2.5.1 ["Locke on 'pure substance in general'"] to get the idea; treat "properties" and "accidents" as synonyms.)
  2. Aug. 29: T I.iii.6, 2 paras. starting "Probability, as it discovers not..." (SB pp. 89f = NN 62f)
  3. Sept. 7 (N.B.: due to Labor Day, the assignment is due on Wednesday): In T I.iv.2, para. 4, starting "That our senses offer not their impressions..." plus the first sentence of the following paragraph (i.e., through "...a kind of fallacy and illusion"), at SB 189 = NN 126.
  4. Sept. 12: Either T I.iv.6, 7th para., starting "Thus the controversy..." (SB 255 = NN166f), or para. 16, "But lest this argument shou'd not convince the reader..." (SB 259f = NN169f).
  5. Sept. 19: EHU sec. 8, pt. ii, 4th para. (starting "The only proper object of hatred or vengeance..."); this is on p. 98 of the Selby-Bigge edition.
  6. Sept. 26: T I.ii.6, from the 2nd para. ("There is no impression or idea of any kind...") through the fifth para. ("This we may without hesitation conclude to be impossible.")
  7. Oct. 3: T I.ii.2 (SB 32/NN 26), from "'Tis an establish'd maxim in metaphysics," to end of the section.
  8. Oct. 10: BONUS WEEKLY ASSIGNMENT! T II.iii.3, para. starting "Since reason alone..." (SB 414f/NN 266).
  9. Oct. 17: In "The Sceptic", para. bridging pp. 164f, starting "But the case is not the same..."
  10. Oct. 24: T III.ii.1, para. beginning "It appears, therefore, that all virtuous actions..." plus the para. beginning "In short, it may be establish'd..." (SB 478-79/NN 307-08).
  11. Oct. 31: EPM, Appendix II, in the second-to-last para. ("But farther, if we consider rightly..."), starting at "Nature must, by the internal frame...", to the end of the paragraph. (In the Selby-Bigge edition, this is on pp. 301f.) Before you outline the argument, look at the 2nd para. of the Appendix, starting "There is another principle..."
  12. Nov. 7: "Of the Original Contract" (in Essays, para. bridging pp. 480-81 (starting "What necessity, therefore...").
  13. Nov. 14: Essays, p. 194, para. starting "My second observation on this head..."; alternatively, if you're looking at the optional reading from Korsgaard, Sources, p. 59, para. starting "Actually, however..."
  14. Nov. 21: Essays, p. 218, para. starting "There is, however..."; you'll need to draw on the previous page, starting with "L'Abbe DUBOS, in his reflections..." (Keep in mind that the Essays are a stylistic shift away from the logic exercises of the Treatise; it takes extra work to pull the structure of the argument out from the conversational flow.)
  15. Nov. 28: Either, in "The Epicurean," on p. 139, from "But of all the fruitless attempts..." to "...of nature's wisdom than of yours," or in "The Sceptic", para. bridging pp. 159f, starting "I have long entertained a suspicion..."
  16. Dec. 5: EHU sec. 2, last para., starting "Here, therefore, is a proposition..." (in the Selby-Bigge, this bridges pp. 21f).
  17. Dec. 12 (Bonus Weekly Assignment): T III.ii.5, para. starting "All morality depends upon our sentiments..." (in the Selby-Bigge, on p. 517; in the Norton and Norton, p. 332).